Why are you skeptical? There is clearly a huge leap in rational intelligence when you go from other animals to humans. I would expect we would eventually find a reason for it.
Citation needed. Monkeys/apes even fight wars between tribes. All differences between humans and other animals seem to be purely quantitative. I'm sure the difference between your average cat and the smartest species of non-human monkeys/apes are greater than the difference between the smartest species of non-human monkeys/apes and your average human.
Nearest neighbor, top down, based on genetic similarity. If you’ve got something, and it seems that it’s only detected in humans, aren’t chimpanzees (or may other great apes) the gold standard for human comparative biology?
Then follow the chain, back through old world monkeys, before reaching rodentia.
So it’s probably less difficult than finding a match for an organ donor, no?
I think they have some currency to start a search for samples, with this first stage finding. But really, as we’re finding out, replication will be important too.
I dont really know what to do with that figure 2e... it looks like they cherry picked stats where they saw a "significant difference" from the other types of cells they looked at.
Are data rights costly? I doubt that sort of information has a shelf life. Consider that HELA cells are still around.
If they release the specific results, and how they arrived at such conclusions, others should be able to take that in hand, and move quickly to look at primate corollaries.
What do you mean by "sufficiently"? Did they check in any animals? Did they provide a list of criteria that, if met, allow definite identification of these cells in an animal? Can you quote these parts of the paper?