BitTorrent files are also content addressable, and the DHT allows for routing to several provider nodes. Only files that are downloaded are shared too.
What's the plus-value of IPFS over BitTorrent in this scenario?
BitTorrent files are also content addressable, and the DHT allows for routing to several provider nodes. Only files that are downloaded are shared too.
What's the plus-value of IPFS over BitTorrent in this scenario?
Also: Being able to inter-link any content-addressed data structures. With IPLD [1], you can link from an IPFS directory to a Bitcoin transaction, to a Git repository, to a Torrent.
[1] https://ipld.io && https://github.com/ipld/ipld#implementations
When I looked at IPFS some months ago, it looked like a lot of on-going work. It wasn't clear to me what was new and what were the reusable components of the project, and what was reused from the past.
In BitTorrent, the DHT for example is a reusable block emerged from previous P2P systems, but it didn't try to reinvent the wheel, and it didn't try to add a FS on top of it, so it solves a specific problem.
"IPFS" does a lot of things at once, it would be clearer if the project was cut into sub-specifications that could be reused with legacy protocols. Tho I believe the project is going into that direction, and for example IPLD emerged from it.
IPLD looks like a real step-forward. It looks like a "federation" of previous content-addressable protocols, to make them work together, rather than trying to compete with them.
BitTorrent + IPLD makes more sense than IPFS to me, more developers have a heard of BitTorrent and they knows what are BitTorrent features, so the introduction of a concept on top of it is easier to grasp.
BitTorrent has content-addressable links: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnet_URI_scheme
You can perfectly form a web with BitTorrent network by sharing e.g. HTML file which links to further resources.
But I agree that in general there are not as many implementations and/or specifications as with BitTorrent.
IPFS is a new fresh brand not (yet) besmirched with piracy, however technically can serve it the same way.