The problem I see is that a lot of the current players in the health system benefit from hidden data and duplicate procedures so it would take a lot of political courage to force them to open up.
The problem I see is that a lot of the current players in the health system benefit from hidden data and duplicate procedures so it would take a lot of political courage to force them to open up.
The problem is that there is no organization which can provide a stable repository for every patient's data and build secure interfaces to thousands of different provider organizations. That's extremely expensive and there's no real business model. Where will the money come from?
How does law enforcement organizations store and exchange case data? That's another area that is likely to be expensive with no real business model - granted, there is no health equivalent of the FBI - maybe there should be.
Also, after the first failure the FBI tried again with a bigger budget and better process and succeeded[1]
This is a though and fiddly problem, there's a reason why Google/MS/etc. have all bailed out. You can't just build something once and let it scale for the whole healthcare system.
Putting the responsibility on the patients to transfer data strikes me as backwards. The vast majority of patients whose lives depend on the easy transfer of records from one organization to another are incapacitated. They have been hit by a car, suffered a stroke, or are moving from one facility to another.
Yes any initiative that relies on the patient to move data around is doomed to failure. Patients need to be able to get access to their data, but to deliver effective care the data has to flow between provider (and payer) organizations.
In terms of exporting data from one HIS system and into another, it's not clear to me that this will every work without more infrastructure. The exported HL7 data from one organization is going to be of little use to another, they would need some very specialized software to mediate between the data in the exported HL7 file and their own systems. Importing it directly into their hospital information systems is simply not going to be possible; their systems won't understand the myriad of idiosyncratic decisions that the other organization has made, often in response to the specific systems they have purchased (scheduling, laboratory, scheduling, etc.)
Other types of data are still problematic.
Even Epic doesn't have the ability to consolidate multiple CDA documents, or even write information directly to the chart. Each one requires manual review. Standards for exchange are not really the problem.
It’s all edges. It’s really grim. And once you have it sorted out, another variation pops up and fails in some new and awful way. Trying to maintain charts with columns and rows for example, basic stuff, in is near impossible. Just when you crack it you find some down stream system you have no control over is transposing rows and messing up records. It’s critical stuff and it’s a mess.
It would be a cool idea if a non-profit organization could handle it. Healthcare organizations would pay a "duty fee" for requesting or sending records. We just need a standard for transporting it. FHIR makes it de facto HTTPS.
The closest analogy I can think of is the Data Communications Company that intermediates smart meter data in the UK between the energy suppliers and end users. As a monopoly, their prices are regulated (well or not is a political problem…) and all the providers have to use them.
If the data exchange was the source of truth, the providers would presumably save some money not having to store their own copies (or at least, could store more summarised versions) with all the requirements that HIPAA/GDPR entail.
However, there’s money to be had for a huge aggregated database of everyone’s health records, stored in consistent format for easy consumption…maybe we should be careful what we wish for.
In an ideal market, another player who didn’t want to hoard data could undercut them (not having that cost).
Tuning either the cost/benefit of outsourcing or the nature of the incentives, I suppose, are the key.