I’m a huge fan of publicly funded media such as NPR and your local public radio station.
Would you rather have the children decide what they should learn in school, or the injured decide how their wound should be dressed? A fundamental aspect of our society's advancement is that we have become specialists: we almost all wear socks but very few of us would know how to make them. And even if we could, we wouldn't be able to make them quite so efficiently.
The poor—or the middle class, or the rich—shouldn't have to decide how they are being informed about the world any more than they should be expected to decide which type of stitching is used to assemble their socks.
Can we agree that mentally stable adult humans, generally, should have some agency and responsibility to choose how they consume media?
I'm not even going to respond to your second paragraph because it's almost insulting that you thought it necessary to ask.
I'm cautiously optimistic that a utility token like BAT, or some other way that people can provide micro-payments for content will win in the end. I'd gladly pay $0.25 to read a well written article on the Internet, so long as it went to the creator and didn't fund the advertising machine.
By the way, for example of not-ad-driven internet you might look at China, where podcasts is $7 bln business (direct fees and subscriptions), video blogging is of course full of celebrities promoting big brands, but for the main part is still about direct "gifts" from viewers to tens of thousands of bloggers.
First, from what I can find, the average click-through rate online for ads is something like 2%. I suspect it's even worse for smaller blogs and independent sources that don't advertise using Google.
Let's assume you're getting a dollar every time someone clicks on an ad. I think that's high, but whatever. If we were to get everyone to start paying for content, that would translate to it costing around 2 cents for you to look at a page. If you're reading 30 articles from your favorite site every month, that's 60 cents a month. So people talk about how expensive content would be, but from what I can see it probably wouldn't take a huge amount of money to give sites the same amount of support that they're getting right now.
Secondly, I think it's at least a little bit problematic to say that ads make content free. The only reason why any company would ever pay to put an ad on someone's content is if they expect to make that money back, either by encouraging consumers to buy a different product than they normally would have, or by encouraging them to buy more of a given product than they otherwise would have. Statistically speaking, you are paying for content that is ad supported. If you weren't, nobody would put ads on that content.
And I realize that sounds a little bit like splitting hairs, but I get tired of this idea that ads don't have a consumer cost. If you completely get rid of ads through ad blockers, and by not listening to radio or watching live TV, and by not using any service that doesn't give you a purchase option... it will not take long until you become re-accustomed to "normal" levels of advertising. And once you are accustomed to that, you will immediately notice on venturing back into the ad-filled world just how much time and attention and mindspace that ads demand from you.
Everyone believes that they're atypical, and that ads don't encourage them to spend more, or to buy branded products instead of generic ones, or to treat practical products like status symbols. Most people are wrong about their own abilities though. Most people are affected by advertising. That doesn't mean that advertising is evil, there are lots of good use-cases for advertising -- but it does mean that ads aren't free.
It would be very hard to gather data on this, but I suspect that if you tracked the average spending habits of people who were inundated with ads, their monthly spending would increase more than the cost of buying a few magazine subscriptions. I suspect that's even true of most people on Hackernews. If anyone has data, they're welcome to prove me wrong though.
It's a straightforward extrapolation from data.
> We are living through a period of rapid global poverty reduction. According to recent estimates, high, sustained growth across most of the developing world has helped nearly half a billion people escape $1.25-a-day poverty between 2005 and 2010. Never before have so many people been lifted out of poverty over such a brief period.
https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/two-trends-in-global-pove...
500,000,000 people, 5 years.