I think they must think it elevates their discourse, as if appealing to emotion at all sullies them. While there is a reassuring sobriety to cold, rational thought, in itself it often doesn't motivate me to care. It's only really effective in preaching to the choir because they've chosen to hobble themselves by using only a third of the tools available to rhetoric. There are ways to rationally appeal to people's sense of ethics and to the full range of human emotions without descending into demagoguery.