If your argument is that many of these charities aren't actually doing useful work, and that they only exist as a way to get tax deductions, is shaky when you consider that you still end up poorer when making a charitable contribution than when you don't (in no case does the deduction exceed the amount donated).
Changing the overall tax rate is bringing a much larger argument into this (tail wagging the dog).
As you point out, it's very possible to raise taxes/eliminate a loophole on a bad policy without giving more money to the government overall.
Sure, the rich give more to charities, but they also pay the most taxes. The net change of parent's proposal would probably be smaller than most people expect for the average charitable person.
Especially considering that many tax-deductible "charities" are actually people getting together to pay each other money for personal services (for example: schools, churches, and hobby associations)
It has been born out in practice that these extra tax payments are not deductible. Few people would expect this to be the case, either. The absurdity does not exist. This is not an intellectually honest argument.
>Especially considering that many tax-deductible "charities" are actually people getting together to pay each other money for personal services (for example: schools, churches, and hobby associations)
Private schools provide an alternative means of educating children when one does not trust the culture or capabilities of the local public schools. Taxing them would reduce their prevalence and would worsen the burden on private parents whose economic activity already supports both public (through property tax, etc) and private schools.
Churches provide moral support to communities, organize deeds of service, and are generally a force for exercising virtue. I say this as an athiest. Some bad churches exist, but taxing churches would be throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
Tax-free hobby organizations are a little less defensible, but it is worth considering that they are limited in scope by law (https://cullinanelaw.com/501c7-social-and-recreational-organ...). But it is worth considering that making it cheaper to fund hobby organizations makes it easier to participate in the sort of activities that we enjoy, and that improve our physical and mental health.
We are already living in a society where we spend every dollar we make, and we still feel lonely and isolated nonetheless. Encouraging these outlets, with their socialization and tight focus on community, is a force for good.
You shouldn't try to play fast and loose with tax breaks for charitable giving because the IRS actually keeps pretty close tabs on that stuff. As far as they're concerned, an organization either has charitable status with them, or the organization does not have charitable status with them. There is no middle ground. Trying to argue that an organization is a charity, and therefore your gift should be tax deductible, is a losing proposition where the IRS is concerned.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kars4Kids
That's just the first example off the top of my head, but also, when someone donates a wing or lecture hall to a school, why do they get to name it? They are gaining prestige and public relations, and admissions status for their descendants. A real charitable donation would be credited to anonymous.
But even then, taxes are for the operation of society, that we as voters have come together and decided on. There just isn't a reason to subvert that with a million other little organizations, even if one were to claim that they are being audited and whatnot, when one can clearly see favoritism in the group's beneficiaries and quid pro quo from the donations.
The rest of your argument is spot-on, but one rebuttal is that charitable giving exemption is a way to provide a truly democratic way for citizens to give votes of partial non-confidence in how their tax dollars are spent.
The only solution is to remove this option period. The US government even negotiated with Scientology where they kept their charity status even after being proven corrupt:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_status_of_Scientology_in_t...
How can anyone take "charity" as a legal term seriously?
The IRS rules state that if the benefit to the donor is quantifiable, it has to be subtracted from the overall amount of the donation. You would have to come up with a reasonable fool-proof rule to quantify those benefits.
For one example, what's a "charitable donation" to a mega church to one person is a scam to let Joel Osteen live like a king without paying taxes to another.
If people "donate" less because they're now getting less "value for money" out of whatever they were buying with their donations, that suggests that these weren't true donations and we're better off with less of them.
The point is that a society needs funds to function, and in a democracy, society gets together and decides what to do with their pooled resources. We vote on what we want to prioritize, such as military, research, education, infrastructure, spying on its own citizens, etc. Everyone contributes to these causes via taxes, except if you set up your own little organization and call it a "charity". Then you can opt out society's liabilities and fund your own little pet causes, regardless of whether or not they are actually beneficial to everyone. And you can increase opacity since you're not subject to open records (like the government should be ideally), and in general, add a layer of bureaucracy for no reason.
I don't see a compelling argument that all the added overhead of lawyers and accountants and inspectors who then need go around checking every stupid charity offset whatever benefit the charity provides. Instead we should be focusing our efforts on making government transparent, reducing waste, and pursuing efforts to benefit all in society.
I think the advantages of charities are along the same lines, smaller organizations can be more efficient, redundancy avoids a single point of failure, etc.
Would I want to rely on charities to provide all essential services? No. But if for political reasons, the government doesn't provide some service I don't think it is a bad thing to have charities around that might be able to mitigate things somewhat.
I guess the tax policy really depends on the numbers for me. If 50% of public spending is charity spending / 50% is gov. that's very high and maybe they should consider scaling back the deductions. But if it's 5% charity 95% government, I'd say leave the deduction alone since charities have a valuable purpose.
This is all independent of preventing any sort of abuse which should be done first, then the remaining number could be looked at.
Why is this stipulated on charitable deductions going away?
It’s not like Tax breaks create new money they just redistribute resources.
I live in Belgium, where the system is a bit different (you get a 45% tax deduction on money donated if a charity has an accreditation) and the tax deduction is a significant part of why I give to charity.
If there would be no deduction, I would still give, but a lot less.
As you say, even the ones you support are not worth giving much of your money to. But, you are also directly supporting charities with your tax money that you actively disagree with.
EX: Direct Food Aid is generally (though not always) considered a bad idea, but if even a small portion of people disagree then everyone chips in.
There's a sort of pre-vetting in the charity's original 501(c)3 application. A charity can also be investigated and stripped of its status if it's found to be non-compliant with the public benefit clause.
But the deduction incentivises giving. I tend to gift double the money I would without the deduction, because the cost is exactly the same to me. The US system is probably too generous when comparing both.
I personally don't oppose the deduction. Most are not investment vehicles but actual charities, doing something good in the world. I wish more people would do something good in the world.
I'm sure more money goes lost every year due to political corruption and graft, than through the charity tax deduction.
Then you give ~exactly the same money, it's the public that's giving more money. Forcing everyone else in your country to chip in just a little more for roads is not the same as giving more money.
One possible answer to 'why' question: Assume the tax rate is 50%. If the deduction encourages someone to give money they wouldn't otherwise, now 100% of the donated money is being used for a society-agreed-upon cause instead of 50% of it. In those cases, you could view it as a spending boost if the goal is to have more money spent publicly.
To me the more important reason is the different structure of public vs private money. If the government was perfect at directing money wisely, there would be no need for private investment or businesses at all. But sometimes there are advantages to a few people directing a small pool of money, instead millions of people directing an enormous pool of money. You can have a greater variety of projects since not everyone needs to agree. And huge organizations can be less efficient/less likely to be held accountable, since even though there are many stakeholders their attention is limited (relative to the scope of what goes on).
I think it's valuable to have a pool of 'risk money' for charitable causes in addition to the much bigger government-directed pool. And keep in mind that money is still directed some by the public with restrictions on what it can be spent on - if those are too lax it might be better to tighten them up than get rid of them all together.
You pick the cause.
An advocacy group like MADD https://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summar... is a charitable donation.
Calling it a 'public good' when people specifically disagree with their viewpoint and someone could also get a tax deduction for supporting a different viewpoint is a net loss to society.
I can't see a difference between that and spending the same money on Beanie Babies or whatever.
Not sure about about 'when people disagree' thing (requiring majority consensus for public goods). It's easy to see this going both ways, in some places politics will disfavor religious groups, in other places it will disfavor birth control, LGBT groups, etc. I think it's OK to encourage public goods overall without requiring consensus (but not counting things that might be zero-sum like political advocacy as public goods).
The better way in the long term would be to pay for the activity one wants to incentivize, just like we do everything else. Obviously, that would expose all the implicit costs and it's more difficult to win elections.
The whole point of democracy is to enable legal equality, political freedom and rule of law.