Are there any actors which are bad for the market?
Are there any actors which are bad for the market?
Shorts are good for price correction, but bad when they start trying to manipulate things in order to get a price correction (shorting a company and then killing the CEO for an extreme example).
For example, one can find many media articles that are almost certainly paid hit pieces against Tesla and Musk. When you have this much short interest, and news organizations that have contributors with financial interests aligned with the shorts, it is inevitable: https://insideevs.com/tesla-short-sellers-media-crusade/
I wish the SEC would begin to crack down on these abuses. Taking a short position against a stock is fine, but using your media connections to publish damaging and in many cases inaccurate stories is libel at best, and fraud at worse.
Those articles are literally just describing things that SolarCity, Tesla, and Musk actually did* (or in the cases of stated goals/promises, failed to do). How does that count as a "paid hit piece"?
If Tesla wanted to remain a media darling it could have done so very easily: just hit the goals it set for itself. Instead, quarter after quarter, it failed to meet those self-stated goals. Quarter after quarter, they embarked on various stunts to distract investors from its failure to meet its self-stated goals, like selling "flame throwers" and other nonsense. And yet, despite the many quarters of lies, Tesla still has enough media goodwill that a single quarter of two of actually meeting its self-stated goals could result in it becoming a media darling again.
Elon though...Doubling down on the pedophilia remarks and attempting to go to war with multiple government agencies when he was clearly in the wrong is a fast track to becoming a laughing stock, and he deserves the self-inflicted negative media attention he's seen these past 3 months.
AFAIK, Tesla never sold flamethrowers, another company (the boring company) did.
And they weren't flamethrowers, more gun-shaped blowtorches.
The big problem with insider information is that it generally represents a breach of fiduciary duty; essentially someone is improperly disclosing a corporate secret.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insider_trading#Arguments_for_.... Even Nobel prize winning economist Milton Friedman argued that insider trading should be legal.
Insiders often also have power over the behaviour of a company, so for example a corporate leader might short his company's stock and then take actions to ruin the business. Or they might release plans for some action that would be seen negatively in the market, depress the stock price, buy, and then change the plans to ones that will attract investors and pocket the difference when the price goes back up. This doesn't improve market information, in fact it's disinformation because those selling on the first announcement were deceived, but how could you prove it?
Maybe they would get caught, maybe not, but legalising insider trading creates an incentive for these sorts of behaviour that would not exist otherwise.
Legalising insider trading wouldn't legalise such behaviour per se, as such behaviour would still constitute a breach of the leader's fiduciary duties. Look for instance at how Musk was prosecuted for doing that kind of thing; such prosecution was unrelated to insider trading laws, and could still occur without them.
Execs have not only access to 'current oil' stores, but basically everything about the company.
It'd be crazy to invest in a company where execs can do as they please, it would be utterly gamified and suppressive to the entire market.
Yes and the price would be near 0 (i.e. 'priced in' crazy risk) because nobody is stupid enough to buy shares from those who have massive leverage over them.
Would you play poker against a guy who can look at your cards, but you can't look at his?
Investing is not just 'putting money in a productive vehicle' it's buying and selling based in information. What person would be stupid enough to trade with someone with a massive information advantage over them?
Nobody.
You'd have only Private Equity firms and execs owning shares, where the PE firms would have some kind of leverage.
There wouldn't be much of a market for equity, there certainly wouldn't be any 'publicly traded companies' because that would be pointless.
It would massively depress the market and lead to considerably less investment.
Even without insider trading laws, it would still be illegal for executives to do things that hurt the company in the name of their own financial gain, as this would be a breach of their fiduciary duty to the company. It's a separate issue to insider trading.
>There wouldn't be much of a market for equity, there certainly wouldn't be any 'publicly traded companies' because that would be pointless.
This is simply false, as evidenced by the size of other markets that lack insider trading laws, like real estate, commodities or cryptocurrency (or equities markets before insider trading regulations were introduced).
Two - there would be absolutely no way to prove in most cases, one way or the other if the 'insiders activity' was damaging or not for the company. For example, a bunch of insiders discover something disastrous and start selling cheap, sending a panic into the value of the stock. Is this 'bad for the company'? Or not? Then the 'problem' turns out to be not such a big deal, and they buy back on the cheap. Was this damaging to investors? Even if the insiders were acting legitimately, i.e. selling when something was wrong, buying when it was not ... it would 100% not be in the best interests of other investors - you see from this example that the very nature of 'insider information' makes 100% of trades by insiders 'not in the interests of other investors'.
"as evidenced by the size of other markets that lack insider trading laws, like real estate, commodities or cryptocurrency
This is wrong.
Real estate can generally be independently valued. That's why it's required by law in many countries to have 'independent' assessments of a home's value. Same can be done with commercial.
In commodities and currency there are no 'insiders'. There's nothing built into the price but the inherent value of the commodity itself. Corn is corn is corn. Insider trading would definitely apply to a big agri-business, but for corn futures, or USD or even Bitcoin - there literally are no 'insiders'.There are 'insiders' in companies, but a market does not have insiders. Just intelligent people researching, analyzing, with their fingers on the pulse.
Demand for stocks would dwindle to nothing without insider trading laws, that's why they exist in every developed market.
I don't exactly know what you mean by irrational actors are good for overcoming a market crisis, but I'd probably say that the market isn't functioning in a crisis and that irrational actors might put it back in a normal state, irrational actors are not good for functioning markets.
I actually have the exact opposite opinion, natural monopolies are good for the market while government granted monopolies are not.
Natural monopolies (i.e., ones not protected by fiat) gained their position through being the best in that space and there's nothing to stop competitors from overthrowing them if they lose their way while the opposite is far from true -- try to overthrow a gov't granted monopoly and you end up in court for patent (or whatever) infringement.
Natural monopolies are bad because they can use their market position to unfairly prevent new entrants to the market. For example, Amazon may buy all of a key supplier's product and prevent the upstart from even having a chance because they can't buy any of that product. The monopoly can raise prices to whatever level they want, despite what the market would dictate because the consumer doesn't have another alternative.
I don't believe monopolies are good, except that having a monopoly might be better than having no market at all. All the rest are just people participating in normal market activity.
I mean, this is a somewhat flippant answer, but anyone engaged in massive fraud: P&Ds, Madoffs, Enrons, etc.