Even if it's not reckless their competitors will offer low light and night time autonomous driving which will be a major advantage.
Even if it's not reckless their competitors will offer low light and night time autonomous driving which will be a major advantage.
Conventional cameras alone are not trustworthy for self-driving, and this is part of the reason every respectable company venturing into self-driving is incorporation technologies like LIDAR.
I find it sketchy that Tesla markets "future full-self-driving" when they are unlikely to have the hardware to make that a safe experience.
Their ability to deliver is a function of the costs of their basic technology supplies (batteries for the Roadster were expensive, less so for the S, X, and energy storage, and now even less so for the 3). This is very similar to the cost decline curve of solar, wind, and storage in the utility energy space (project developers provide bids based on where prices will be in 3-5 years).
Tesla can do this because technology and batteries rapidly decreases in cost every year. Need new autopilot compute hardware? It should be cheaper by the time they need to perform the swap to realize the capability. Need LIDAR? They'll find a way to install it, and the costs should be fairly reasonable per vehicle instead of thousands, or tens of thousands, if they went all in when it was expensive.
This is not unlike a technology startup, where technical debt you're going to pay off in the future is an acceptable tradeoff, so you push off the decision and/or work until the last possible moment (but no further).
And relating it to technical debt makes no sense as you have to design with LIDAR in the beginning.
Everyone is partnering with someone or organising supply deals. And everyone other than Tesla uses LIDAR.
Also I never said these cars were being sold today.
Then you're moving the goal posts. Tesla is selling cars today to people that they are (EDIT) targeting support of full autonomy, or have their hardware swapped to do so. Everything else is an experiment in a lab or on a track.
Well, Tesla claims that. It's quite possible that neither will happen.
An incredibly dangerous one.
https://thehill.com/policy/transportation/automobiles/315133...
> Federal regulators "did not identify any defects" in Tesla's autopilot feature after a lengthy investigation of the technology, officials announced Thursday.
> A six-month investigation failed to uncover any flaws with the autopilot's emergency breaking technology and other advanced features linked to a deadly accident last year, according to a National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) report released Thursday.
> "NHTSA’s examination did not identify any defects in design or performance of the AEB or Autopilot systems of the subject vehicles nor any incidents in which the systems did not perform as designed," the NHTSA report said.
I think Tesla is bang on the money going only with cameras. They are already better than the human eye.
Because it compensated for poor sensor hardware with a processing unit and software that we have thus far been unable to even come close to replicating? Granted, solve that, and we’re just a few years away!
People seriously misjudge the limitations of these sensors, and this leads to accidents.
Better to use cameras, which have almost exactly the same issues humans have (e.g. bad vision in low light, limited view, "blind" angles near corners, bad optical performance near the edges, ...), which will lead to "understandable" mistakes.
Nobody will understand if a LIDAR misses a beam sticking out of a truck in front of you (which would be expected behavior: such a thing is essentially invisible to LIDAR) and impales the person sitting in the passenger seat on it.
Or the Tesla fuckup. Failing to see the difference between front and back wheels of a large truck and 2 cars. Then decapitating the driver by driving in between the 2 sets of wheels at high speed. That's a typical LIDAR issue.
Sooner or later LIDAR will decide that just driving off an abyss is the best solution to a simple traffic situation (because LIDARs see abysses everywhere, so they use algorithms that assume abysses don't exist).
I've seen LIDAR controlled robots drive into tables "decapitating" (sort-of) themselves, because it only saw the feet of the table, looking at the data, and coming to the conclusion ... yep ... it was a perfectly understandable mistake. That robot also threw itself off the stairs. Again ... tough to fault it for that, as it saw the stairs as pretty much the same thing as a stick lying on the floor. Afterwards looking at the data, that was a perfectly reasonable conclusion.
We lost the robot to the stairs. I was looking at it making that decision. Why ? You see it move, and you're automatically assuming "surely it's not going to go for the hole in the staircase". And then it decides on a solution. Boom. And yes, I pressed the emergency stop button. Doesn't help much if the robot is already falling.
Surely, he cries, the argument is to use both and simply apply use some kind of likelihoods/confiendence in the output to combine them?
Hint: it’s not due to the sensor package being used.
But it is. The package is pretty limited, and the firmware running it is full of hacks that compensate. Hiding the blind spot, saccade masking, not paying attention to stationary things...
This has consequences. It takes them forever to find anything, even if they can do it from great distances. They are blind for several seconds when they change position (such as when they just caught prey), or just generally at short range.
And you can try this with cats: this makes it very easy to sneak up on them. No peripheral vision, directional hearing ... if they're focused in front of them, you can almost just walk up to them from the back, they won't notice.
These things are tradeoffs. Humans are prey species, pack hunters. If a human is paying attention you can't really hope to sneak up on them. One human is easy to take down. But 10 humans will defend each other effectively.
I'm not accusing you of any of this, just pointing out that a seemingly innocuous, almost cliched term like "evolutionary ladder" can carry a lot of unwelcome baggage.
So can digital cameras.
> And of course SONAR exists in whales, dolphins etc which is a corollary.
The reason for (active) SONAR is the lack of ambient sound. An alternative for a car would be headlights. Or passive infrared cameras.
Tesla is cutting corners by eschewing a well-known technology that will increase the fidelity of their autonomous driving system. That is irresponsible.
Do. No. Harm. It isn't just for Doctors. You can't sit on the positivist side of the fence and say, "Bah, it'll never happen."
It always does. When the cost is lives, you don't mess around or skimp. Closer to Perfection over pretty good is 100% justifiable in safety critical applications. In many cases, critical systems are redundantly reinforced.
Look up risk compensation to understand why a half-baked solution is almost guaranteed to be worse. If you are still relying on the human to compensate for failures in a system in an environment where response time to live is measured in seconds, you might as well just have them being alert and engaged at all times with as few things to have to compensate for malfunctioning as possible.
Another somewhat tangential demonstration of this is observable in nuclear reactor design, and utilising delayed fission product neutrons to attain criticality. This slows down the timescale over which things can go horribly wrong to the scale of minutes instead of seconds that would make avoiding prompt criticality highly problematic.