I think it's great that the townspeople who do value libraries are telling the outsiders to fuck right off. People in American cities and towns have been subsidizing their exurban and rural neighbors for many decades, while those people have systematically and intentionally undermined the very cities and towns that benefit them. At some point the proponents of civilization have to draw a line.
It's obvious you don't use libraries, because you left out a couple dozen other services they provide that are not easily replaced. I'm also not sure how a community center is supposed to be easily replaced without tax revenue.
While the "libraries are outdated" line is oft-repeated, it's still inaccurate. Libraries provide large economic impacts, on top of less easy to measure things like being community centers. Here's one article about a study that shows for every $1 in tax put towards a library, it generates anywhere from $2.50-$5.00+ in economic benefit, depending on how you measure it: https://www.toledoblade.com/local/2016/04/28/Toledo-Lucas-Co...
If you google for more, you'll find a dozen other examples.
Perhaps an office in city hall could have computer 24/7 or other things.
I like libraries - but they shouldn't be welfare/job centers -- we should build institutions that specialize in that and can be evaluated on their effectiveness.
Any of the various other places that happen to be around where you can congregate, like a park with a gazebo.
The value of publicly accessible computers and printers is obvious, I'm just not so sure about all the other things that a library does. I'm curious exactly how this study quantifies all this.
The problem is, all this stuff isn't freely available online.
Yes, there is enough online information online to put together a 6th grade essay on the Battle of Gettysburg. But if you actually want a more-then-superficial understanding of a subject, you will, at some point, hit the shelves, and crack open a dozen books.
The classics may be freely out of copyright, but books that analyse them aren't. Most of the literature of the 20th century is still under copyright.
There are thousands of free online courses, each of which would cover ~100 pages in a book. Yet, there are over a hundred million published books. Many of them are out of date, or dreck. And many of them contain information that you won't find on the internet - for any price, and definitely not 'free'.
You will find many of them at your library, though (Or available through inter-library loans). Another thing that you will find at your library is a librarian, who can help you figure out what you are should be looking for. Google won't do this for you.
Just because you can, in five seconds, find a half-baked, incomplete blog post tutorial on how to ship HelloWorld in the flavor-of-the-week-crap.js framework, doesn't mean that a library is useless in 2018.
In addition to all the great content you can find free online, libraries get free access to EBSCO databases.
I've also never needed the help of a librarian, ever.
Having the old books around will remain useful only up until the point we find a way to fully digitize all of it and make "borrowing" solutions more widespread/work around the copyright issues. For now for 99% of cases you don't need a physical book.
Unfortunately my ereader doesnt provide the community with a quiet place for the less fortunate or a way to read those digitized books you have.
A library is not just a place of books, it is a place of learning for those who arent in college who like to learn on their own .... not to get an A.
Most of the time, you don't even have to look at anything not on the prescribed reading list.
Palo Alto/MV are considered one of the thought capitals of America, so that's not a clear correlation. If Boston's library's are full, I'm sure Detroit's library would be too. I wouldn't think that Boston/Manhattan/Palo Alto library use would have any correlation to half of America.
Also, anyplace where rent ranges are higher free study space is more valuable.
http://www.pewinternet.org/2016/09/09/a-portrait-of-those-wh...