We also have a full copy on our CI server (which is hosted on another service, so still not "in-house"), and we have a copy of at least the master branch (and all it's history) on our production boxes (which also gets pulled into our whole backup system there).
In a disaster recovery scenario, that's more than enough for me.
Sure, if github blinked out of existence we would probably be at a fraction of our normal productivity for a while until we fully recover everything and find new workflows, but the risk vs reward there is well within the margins of what I'd consider acceptable for a company like us.