This seems like a false dichotomy in that (for the foreseeable future) we have other options, like retraining people whose jobs have been automated away. This is strictly better (read "less invasive" and "more economically efficient") than wealth redistribution programs [^1].
[^1]: To avoid the motte and bailey fallacies that accompany poorly-defined or otherwise ambiguous terms such as "redistribution", I'm referring to the typical redistribution programs which take wealth from one group and give it to another group with no net increase in economic productivity. These are the kinds of programs which are controversial and objectionable.