I think your arguments ignore many of the actual economic costs of a solar panel installation. The mounting framework is the cheapest part of the structure. The solar panels themselves are expensive, but the major issue with your idea to re-install them every few years would be the labor costs. It takes a few hours and a few men to install the panels, so throwing in $1000 every 2-3 years would make this type of quick-replace plan non-cost effective.
I'm not an expert in solar panels by any stretch, but my understanding that the two major breakthroughs we need are a) how to make the solar panels themselves more efficient over a long life-span. Typically they lose 2-4% of their efficiency every year, meaning 20 years down the road, they've lost 50% of their energy power. b) a more efficient converter from the DC generated by the solar cells to the AC we put back into the grid.