I wouldn't call those 3-4 hours closing down for the night. Even so, this break is used mostly for track maintenance where one can't have trains rolling.
Station cleaning and rolling stock maintenance is ongoing, construction/repairs that do not require cutting electric power to the trains are being done 24/7.
So, no excuse for NY.
Simply put, 24/7 is not as big of an obstacle to cleanliness as you make it out to be.
As other people mentioned, too, most of the work done in the evenings is track maintenance.
I used to live at the end of a line, and no matter the time of day there was very often a cleaner waiting by the frontmost door as the train pulled in. They could usually remove any litter before the train was due to leave, perhaps 5-8 minutes later.
The service is less frequent overnight (Friday and Saturday only), which leaves plenty of time to clean more thoroughly at the depot.
But I think that's a distraction. In comparison, NYC's subway looks dirty
a) by lack of maintenance. Some areas just need fresh paint.
b) by design. Bare concrete, unfinished, gloomy ceilings, yellow-ish lights, grey trains.
In other situations (shopping mall, fast food) Americans have remarked to me that Europe can seem clinical, due to the high temperature of the lighting. I think those places, and the NYC subway, look dingy. The same light could look cosy, but only in a café or bar.
Combined, the information shows they do a "deep clean" on every train every 21 days, and it takes four hours per carriage.
Then 15 minutes per carriage just under twice per day per carriage.
I suspect the cleaning I saw isn't part of this, but is the station cleaning staff feeling it's easier to pick the litter from the train rather that wait for wind to blow it out and around the station.
https://tfl.gov.uk/corporate/transparency/freedom-of-informa...
https://tfl.gov.uk/corporate/transparency/freedom-of-informa...
What's the point of 24/7 schedule, when it takes an hour and a half during the night for your train to arrive?
Idk, I think I might've preferred them to shut the train down say 12pm-6am to give them time to improve whatever they need to. It would be much more useful to know the exact time it would take me to get places. Trains at night are pretty empty, I think with some adjustment, it wouldn't be a big deal for people, but maybe there is more to it.
EDIT: edited percentage to 20-30%
I found the NYC subway to be fairly decent but I found the feeling of darkness in many stations to be more of a big deal. I wouldn't mind waiting in stations that were much lit much better.
I’m not usually one to defend the MTA but this is wildly inaccurate.
"Instead of having a reliable system 20 hours a day let's have an unreliable system 24 hours a day" doesn't seem to make sense.