Here's my particular case. I've been a subscriber since the third issue and 90% of the magazine content I've seen on HN, but the presentation and centralization of the best is of wonderful value. They really do a nice job on the design front. The issues also function like a library of cool articles you can show to a friend or colleague and say "Here's HN in a box, at least one particular filtering of it." I have brought at least a couple contributors to Hacker News, just because they read through an issue of Hacker Monthly.
Whenever you hear the word value, you should ask yourself, "of value for what, and to whom?" The hedge fund manager who reads the WSJ may get millions of dollars worth of value out of it. The business school student may only get the $199/yr he pays.