> "If thumbs-ups or ratings on a five-point scale are not automatically useful, what kind of feedback would be? Finely tuned feedback that targets the system it’s meant to regulate will always surpass a barrage of angry or ecstatic reviews. Rather than trumpeting the desirability of all feedback, apps and review sites should pursue only the information that is crucial for making the system work better."
It's hard to know what data points correlate to making the system work better until after the fact — so developers generally have to "over ask" so you can back test data to outcomes.
Probably the best criticism of the proliferation around feedback is that it doesn't always make the customer's experience better, it just creates better conditions for the company to make more money.