> Nobody claimed otherwise.
Yes, you did, when you said: “If it's ethically defensible to abort fetuses for no particular reason (i.e. general legalized abortion)”
That is an explicit statement that the legality of abortion necessarily implies the ethical acceptability of abortion.
> > it can mean that the perceived incidental costs of policing it outweighs the benefits.
> That's an ethical defense.
It's an ethical defense of the legality of a thing that does not depend on the ethical acceptability of the thing itself.
> We can disagree about the costs and benefits of abortion or genetic engineering, but purely based on principles I don't see how you can defend non-medically indicated abortion but not genetic engineering.
One can defend the legality of non-medically indicates abortion but not designer babies theogh genetic engineering because one believes that permitting government inquiry into the justification of abortion (given the fallibility and corruptibility of government) poses an unacceptably high risk of intrusion into legitimate bodily autonomy that is not warranted by the benefits of the prohibition, whereas the same is not true with human genetic engineering (either because the latter does not as closely impact legitimate bodily autonomy issues or because the potential public impacts of each instance of gene editing warrant accepting greater costs to control it.)