Really, all of this is bullshit, because the reason we sometimes fail to deliver software projects is humans really suck ass at dealing with complexity. We can deal with one complex thing at a time, but once multiples of them are all being considered at once, we just screw up constantly.
I think the way to pick any methodology is really deceptively simple: 1) look around and see if most of you are experienced at a given methodology, and then 2) use it.
I think it's that second part that people screw up on.