Wow, I always assumed that complex life prior to our own was unlikely because it would have left a trace that we could detect. But if there is a plausible mechanism by which all such traces would have been erased, then who knows what might have happened deep in those billions of years when supposedly only single-celled life existed?
Perhaps Earth’s previous inhabitants triggered runaway global cooling, effectively hitting the reset switch back to single-celled life. Perhaps they escaped to Venus and vowed not to let the same thing happen there, but got it wrong in the other direction.