It's sad to me that people were so hard on him for his last works. I wish mathematics had a positive space for speculation.
People were mostly just sad that journalists were hyping up an obvious case of age-related cognitive decline from a brilliant Mathematician.
And to be clear, Atiyah's last work wasn't speculation – it was completely off, in the "not even wrong" category. Unfortunately, that's pretty common as people get older, but there's no reason to publicize it.
Are there other examples of this in Mathematicians? Nash and Godel come to mind, but both of them had non-math-related issues.
this is my theory anyway.