Hacker News Reader

I meant this particular journal.

I'm sure there is honest discussion within the field generally.

This is not name-calling to pull this hoax. It's an demonstration (or experiment if you like).

You can discuss all you like but at some point we need a demonstration.

Nullius in verba 'n all that.

It doesn't demonstrate anything that isn't entirely comparable to the replication crisis, which stretches across many, many fields and many journals that the authors would almost certainly not call "grievance studies".

It certainly doesn't demonstrate that there is any "corrupting academic research" going on.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com