Hacker News Reader

#thanksobama for throwing taxpayer money at GM, only to have them do their inevitable restructuring a few years later than otherwise.

View on HN

The "GM" that got the money was already restructured, it is "new GM", the shareholders in old GM were wiped right out.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motors_Liquidation_Company

Propping up GM legitimately helped hundreds of thousands of workers. Whether it was a good use of the money is a different question than that, but the money didn't go to shareholders, it went to keeping the operations going.

It's impossible to tell exactly what would have happened in a bankruptcy, but the entire company would have almost certainly been restructured, which would have meant generally clearing out the dead wood: shuttering factories, renegotiating anachronistic/extravagant union contracts, etc.

Coercing private citizens to pay for mismanaged companies and subsidize the gold-plated pension benefits of Baby Boomer employees is utterly immoral.

If you click the link I gave up there, you'll see that it was reorganized in a bankruptcy.

Yeah, its not like the sitting president introduced 25% steel tariffs and 10% aluminum tariffs or anything.

Yep, tariffs are probably a bad idea. Obama did those too (his economic ignorance knew no bounds). Two wrongs don't make a right.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com