You can have your cake and eat it too, it turns out.
That is why some places started to use hybrid system. One single line until very end where someone marshals you at the end of many very short lines.
Imagine four lines arranged next to each other, at the head of eight registers arranged similarly to a self-checkout area. There will always be four people at the head of the lines. The first person in the first line gets to go, then the first person in the second line, then the first person in the third line, then the first person in the fourth line, and then it cycles back.
Because in practice it is extremely rare for four out of eight registers to simultaneously open up, the next person is always at the front of their line already, which avoids this particular travel distance problem.
The way this particular one works is with color codes -- there are four color-coded lanes, and when a cashier becomes available, they are announced by the system, which cycles through the colors.
It has some failure modes.
In the "dilute limit", if a customer approaches the lines and there's nobody else there, there's no indication of which color was last called or which is next, so they have to guess. If they guess wrong and someone else shows up and guesses right before a cashier becomes available, they might lose out. This effect goes away once the system acquires "memory", by having people in the queue who have seen the last cashier announcement.
At moderate congestion, it can be hard to assess which lane is shortest, because people don't space themselves evenly, and sometimes go up in groups. People have a pretty strong sense of fair play, and I've seen people grumbling when the system breaks the expected FIFO dynamic.
But, generally speaking, it works better than I thought it would when they first set it up.
The Whole Foods that I live near now uses a single line heading to multiple express registers, as well as traditional checkouts. This seems to be the worst of both worlds; not only can I not tell which traditional checkout will finish first, I also can't really tell how long the single express queue is actually moving! Are registers opening up at a regular pace or are they opening in waves? It's honestly the worst.
As a result, when I was at the front of line “A” and the computer called “next” after the other lines had gone, I went forward, but another customer did too. The other customer ended up cussing me out for going ahead of him – it turned out he was in a “D” line that, from my “A” line, looked like part of the “C” line. Being yelled at for not understanding the rules of a poorly explained system made for a unpleasant experience.
Same thing; never had a concern with it. But whole foods and fry’s are bigger and I end up spending a good deal of time there just shopping uaually, so queue length isn’t as concerning as when I’m in a smaller grocery, just grabbing a gallon of milk
You may read that as you please.
"This isn't rocket science bro. Obviously more lines = faster."