Thanks Patrick, I agree with these points actually. I guess I didn't make that clear.
I don't think I mentioned in the article to ask for their friends' email addresses though, did I? I'll have a re-read.
At the time, I seem to recall that we very specifically mentioned to our users that they would gain their high score ratings (over time) AND they would be notified of PopJam's launch, via email.
I'm very much a "white hat" guy - so if there's anything you think in there that may be considered grey/black, let me know and I'll remove it from the article. I'm all for best practices.