Can someone tell me how this is different from: "After dissolving the partnership, Mike decided to launch a conference of his own."... And why that should be a sue-able offense?
Even IF Mike was talking to AOL first, he has the right to sell TC (without the LLC) and the acquirer has the right to launch a competing conference (unless there were written agreements to the contrary which no one has mentioned).
Jason, it's all about execution. If you guys parted ways, you're both welcome to create new conferences (were there pre-existing agreements to the contrary?). IMO, 90% of the value of the TechCrunch50 was the TechCrunch brand.