I think Jasons argument is that he created proprietary value in the form of partnerships, sponsorships and acquaintances that Arrington has leveraged with his "new" and successful conference.
It might be a justifiable argument, but that's for a judge to decide. My opinion is that even with those sponsorships, partnerships etc.. that Arringtons probably leveraged TechCrunch the most to create both successful conferences. I`m sure this is something he argues.