My objection is not to the formulation of the rule, but to the existence of the rule―because where I'm from, a little girl is still a girl, grammatically too.
(Even though I agree in general that little kids make crappy men and women.)
(Even though I agree in general that little kids make crappy men and women.)
You could still argue, that the "-chen"-rule should be overwritten by an "obvious-grammatical-gender"-rule.