Some immigration is in the collective interest but all isn't and suggesting otherwise is counterproductive.
What? You want to argue all? Okay - what's the collective benefit in importing folks convicted of genocide? There are lots of groups whose collective cost is higher than their collective benefit. (Yes, we grow some of the locally, but that's not a reason to increase the supply.)
The "let's import all the smart people" advocates have been played for saps by the open borders folk.