Even more unfortunately, bureaucracies, including every modern corporation and government, are UnFriendly AIs. You must comply with the letter of the law because not a single agent involved, not the regulators writing the law nor the courts that will interpret the law nor your competitors that will bring complaints against you nor even the users of the products involved, knows or cares what the spirit is. They don't have the correct value systems, experiences, philosophical frameworks, or cognitive architectures to execute the "comprehend human values" step that would be required to interpret the "spirit" of the law. That incapability is why an even minimally functional justice system needs things like checks and balances and case law and jurisprudence and rules of evidence and all of those things. But we do need those things, because history has proven universally that the letter of the law is the only thing that matters.
On the one hand, this means we literally can't trust any organization composed of more than approximately two people. You often can't even trust organizations with one person, simply because bureaucracy is a force-multiplier even for single humans; think about things like bug trackers and source-control systems and apply them to other workflows. On the other hand, this means that it's pretty much worthless to try to do anything about any individual corporation. Up to the point where you entirely obliterate their industry you're stuck. Which is, coincidentally, what an antitrust action really is - antitrust actions happen exactly when a single agent has taken over an entire industry, and making sure that that an identical bad actor doesn't reappear requires not just breaking it up but also obliterating its industry and introducing a new one with similar features but substantially different (non-agglutinative) dynamics.
Standard disclaimers: Views don't represent employer, etc.
Aka, Google would've still likely been violating GDPR if they had a proper DPO in Ireland, but given how favorable Ireland is to the international companies it harbors the EU legal entities for, it's possible Google would've more successfully evaded punishment, had they been set up to ensure the case got handled in Ireland, rather than France.
Always better to be engaged with an enforcement agency in a country that collects revenue from you.
It can be a huge challenge to prevent a situation like the Eastern District of Texas and patent lawsuits, and that sort of situation can harm both sides.
For some context on why: consider those "cookie" notices you see on every site now. The notices are often obtrusive, usually don't have a "no" button, don't make it clear how to withdraw your consent if you do click "yes"... So if every company is in violation, and no one knows how to do it correctly even with millions of reasons why... Then how exactly is it going to protect user privacy in the real world?
EU companies have as much or more stake in being compliant than the few US tech giants active on EU soil.
I see the impact of the GDPR on EU based companies every week and it is definitely moving the needle towards more secure operations and a much better attitude towards stewardship of data-subject related data.
The fines are not what has made things getting more secure, the work done to avoid the fines is.
Before the GDPR pretty much every company I looked at had absolutely terrible security, since the GDPR is in effect most companies at least stopped seeing security as a cost to be avoided, with an associated increase in awareness at the rest of the company and better processes and controls to ensure that data does not leave the servers when it isn't intended that way.
It's 91 fines so far, and a whole pile of warnings and interventions, give it a few years and the cumulative effect will be substantial.
Oh, and that 10K number is only the breaches that the companies are aware of and that have been reported, the real number is likely to be much higher. And without the GDPR it would be much higher still.
I'm European and I barely use anything made by European tech companies in terms of final products. I'm sure there are some networking chips or similar in some of the devices I use, but the major software and hardware I use is made and designed outside of the EU.
Now I would argue that the reason we don't have many major tech companies in the EU is because of a hostile environment for them here. I really can't think of many other reasons. The EU has more people than the US that are about as educated. There's at least a comparable amount of capital around, our internet connectivity is actually better, but we have very few major tech companies, even fewer ones that focus on internet stuff.
Why is this important? Because if eventually we want to build automation to do other jobs then we need a lot if qualified tech workers.
That’s not accurate. One ≠ a few. The only major European tech company is SAP.
Not going to spend more than two minutes on this, by the time you do some more reading you will likely end up with 100+ companies on this list.
I regret I was unclear, using tech instead of software. The top five most valuable companies in the world are all US software companies. The only European software company on that list is SAP. Oracle, Netflix and Salesforce also make the cut. SAP is worth 15% of Apple, 25% of Facebook, just barely less than Netflix. Alibaba and Tencent are in the global top ten.
China has big tech companies like the US does. Europe does not.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/263264/top-companies-in-...
China and the US have a huge single language market. The EU has a single market with tons of languages. It's much harder for a British or German startup to spread EU wide equivalent to how a US startup can achieve reach across the US and Canada. The EU single market only partially mitigates the problem. Single language seems to count much more than a single jurisdiction.
The usual pattern is when someone in the EU gets interesting, they get bought by a larger US outfit. I don't think China yet allows full foreign takeovers, or a selection of their majors might now be US owned or shuttered too. The other standout in your list, Samsung, is a typical huge conglomerate - TVs, monitors, phones, cameras, memory, storage etc, and part of the larger conglomerate with fingers in everything from fridges to ship building.
I’m sure there are many, many reasons the EU only has one software company to compare with the US or China’s behemoths but the fact remains that it does only have one. There are 16 European companies (including Swiss) in the world top 100, minimum, so I don’t see any special reason Europe couldn’t have software companies that are a really big deal outside SAP but compared to the US they don’t.
As to standouts Toyota is also an enormous conglomerate though you need to expand the list to get to 32. Taiwan Semiconductor is pretty impressive, worth more than Toyota and no one knows it exists.
That's the 'cookie law'[1], not the GDPR. As I understand it, you don't have to provide a way to say no. You just have to notify people before doing it.
[1] Privacy and Electronic Communications Directive 2002
Not even that, the "cookie law" is grossly misunderstood, since it already allowed things like "session cookies" and other account related settings/preferences without any sort of banner. What it banned/didn't allow (at least not without warning) is 3rd party/ad tracking cookies. Some companies just added blanket warnings "to be safe", everyone started mimicing that and now we have the insanity that is modern web publishing...
This is what I think as well. The attitude EU politicians (especially German and French) have taken against foreign tech companies is incredibly hostile. I assume they do this because we don't have many large tech companies in the EU. If they hurt foreign tech companies enough then perhaps there's a chance we might get some in the EU ourselves. What they don't understand is that the reason the EU doesn't have many major tech companies is because the environment is hostile towards them.
Think back on when Zuckerberg was at the EU Parliament and he was asked to name an EU competitor to Facebook to show that they're not a monopoly.