Shouldn't the burden of proof of financing lie with the state before property possession is carried out? It is unfair for the defendant to prove the source of funds for his own property
Shouldn't the burden of proof of financing lie with the state before property possession is carried out? It is unfair for the defendant to prove the source of funds for his own property
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset_forfeiture#United_States
One reason might have been if it was the proceeds of drug-dealing. But that reason is not relevant since he could prove otherwise (let alone whether the burden of proof is/should be on him).
The other reason is simpler: States can fine people for stuff, but (according to the USSC) the fine can't be excessive.
Or more precisely, evil people will happily violate entire tranches of law while the good people are stuck prosecuting one case at a time, painfully establishing precedent by precedent, and in the meantime the world has moved on.
It has to be less illegal to defend yourself from authority if you feel you're in danger.