Most issues in software fall into this category, though. The issue with Java’s null is that it’s not type safe. The language is generally a strongly typed language, except in the case of null. And until Value Types land, there is no way to express nullability to the compiler.
The arguments you make aren’t all that different than the undefined behavior arguments with C. “Just follow these simple rules and you’ll avoid all issues”, a compiler should do that for you IMO.
I can’t wait for Value Types in Java, at that point we can have real Option types.