In this case, though, it's not that he had such an impression. It's that he didn't know he was a Korean citizen.
If draft is a social contract, what do you call a contract where one of the parties never consented to it and wasn't even aware that someone signed them up without their consent, and then the other party tries to enforce it?
But if you're born a citizen in a country with conscription, then you're underage - and thus unable to opt-out on your own, even if you could somehow afford it - until you're 18. And then they hand you the summons.
Only if you're able to obtain another citizenship. I don't think any country will allow renunciation if it leaves you stateless.
“social contract” is, at best, a very weak metaphor in any of it's uses.
"If you have some connection with another country – for example, by birth, by descent through either parent, by marriage or by residence – you may be a national of that country as well as being a British national. ... You may still have certain responsibilities with that country, such as compulsory military service."
Citizenship status should be "opt-in" not "opt-out" or "no option" at all.
If my country would enforce this (It doesn't) I should have the equal opportunity to renounce my german citizenship in favour of the iranian citizenship...
This also happens in the West as well.
And last but not least, this my opinion, I am not forcing this onto anyone -- and if I am of the opinion that this concept of "citizenship as hostage" is BS, I can make that opinion public. This touches the sovereignty of those states in no way, except when this sovereignty is enforced on people that are not part of the society of that country, and have lived 95% of their lives in another country.
In practice, most societies do not allow arbitrary individuals to choose to come and join them; immigration restrictions are a thing pretty much everywhere.
If you have lived 34/35 years in this country and came over with your parents than it is not an "arbitrary choice" you do an a whim.
But I know what you mean -- This is an idea of how [in my opinion] it should work, not the way it actually works...
If you are in Finnish army then you will fight against your other country. But Finnish army doesnt allow being member of multiple armies. So if you have gone trough, as an example, US service Finnish army wont accept you. And if you go to US army after gaining rank in Finnish army you lose the Finnish rank and are just a civilian.