We're talking a hypothetical that might require legislative changes, which isn't too far-fetched if the problem keeps growing. Also, I'd argue that not vaccinating a kid is also not in the child's interest, and not in the interests of that child's classmates.
Education is compulsory and a constitutional right where I live (Romania) and we have problems with low vaccination rates here as well. I'm question at which point do we put the well being of the pack above the individual's rights.
In Australia they went for a different approach - just make it really expensive by not allowing government subsidies and tax breaks for parent who don't vaccinate.
Well, there are rules for parents failing to send their kids to school. Ultimately authorities can take away guardianship from the parents.
“We learn about a vaccine’s safety during clinical trials before it is licensed, and monitor it continually as millions of doses are administered after it is licensed. We also know there is not a plausible biologic reason to believe vaccines would cause any serious long-term effects. Based on more than 50 years of experience with vaccines, we can say that the likelihood that a vaccine will cause unanticipated long-term problems is extremely low.“
https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/parents/tools/parents-guide/par...
> how many children have died in recent years from not getting a vaccination
There's actually not a straight forward answer to that question, because its an (unintentionally) loaded question. Lets focus it specifically on Measles. The natural death rate from measles is not high. Couple that with herd immunity that most non-vaccinated children benefit from, and high quality medical treatments available in (e.g.) the US, and you'd expect it to be low. Definitely higher than the death rate from vaccines, but low. But that's excluding both morbidity, and side-effects of Measles. There's this false belief that getting viruses (like Measles) and surviving them make you stronger. The opposite is more common -- Measles in particular opens you up to re-infection from things you already had because it partially wipes out your immune system. Some viruses are not as bad, others are even worse (e.g. might tilt your immune system towards cancer). After all, viruses are hijacking your body's cellular replication machinery and if they happen to muck with some other stuff in the process, what do they care? Do you think that is a fair answer to your question?
As for honest debates, you'll find a great deal fatigue on the vaccine side, because frankly vaccines have decades of studies, evidence, and readily available information supporting their use. Of all the medical interventions available, they are the cheapest, safest, and most effective measures available, and perhaps the greatest breakthrough medicine will ever have.
I think the inner cynic in me is troubled by the total heap on attitude of everyone towards the subject, so much so that now I think any discussion of it is blocked on Facebook and other socials. It seems like I missed the public debate on this and other topics because I didn't have social accounts, I don't know.
If you or anyone else has any suggestions for any non-politicized books on the matter, I would be happy to report back on my thoughts afterwords.
I guess it depends on the education system in question, as some of them, like mine, are more focused on memorizing facts instead of questioning them.