Hands down it's that UX for me that causes me to use PayPal whenever it is available, but if it's not available I don't mind having to input my card 9 times out of ten.
It's harder to make that kind of mistake in a Paypal integration so if I'm buying from someone outside of my comfort zone I'll look to use Paypal.
Stripe also makes that kind of thing more difficult to do accidentally. I've occasionally had a look to see if a company used stripe.js before putting in my details.