From the feeling the 2018/3rd gen butterfly keyboard is much better. The feedback while typing is much better but if I wouldn't make some of my money with iOS development I wouldn't had bought a MacBook (Air in my case).
For my main work where I get a company device I now ordered a non Apple device which is also repairable after the warranty runs out. I fear to become victim of the flexgate where it seems opening and closing your MacBook makes the display cable break...
Edit: they also improved the usb-c ports. They have a clip-feeling now while my 2017 MBP sometimes doesn't charge because the ports are already wonky. such a bad hardware