Hacker News Reader

One personal gripe I have is that the UX for reviewing a PR commit by commit is non-existent in Bitbucket. Github recognises that a commit is part of a PR and gives you next and previous buttons to move between the commits in the PR.

Draft PRs are also a great Github feature.

View on HN

There is with on-prem bitbucket (formerly Stash).

Annoyingly there isn't on gitlab. It's such a pain for us that it's stopping us moving to gitlab.

Hey, is this the feature you'd like to have in GitLab https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/39380? It's already being evaluated, actually it's a WIP.

Yes, this is it! The default behaviour of gitlab was actually rather unexpected to me in that it cleverly gives the pull request a version which persists after rebasing etc. But I actually expected that drop down to let me switch between the commits in the PR. We use a process of amending PRs using fixups and only rebasing at the end because it allows other developers to easily pull the branch. Being able to step through the commits would be the best of both worlds.

Is it available with Bitbucket Cloud too?

Isn't there a drop-down in Bitbucket that lets you choose between commits?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com