The hardest thing to take a photo of is a black haired cat, and I don't think that's because Adobe is biased agains black cats.
The hardest thing to take a photo of is a black haired cat, and I don't think that's because Adobe is biased agains black cats.
1. There have been instances of photos of black people being postprocessed to make their skin darker. For example, OJ Simpson's mug shot on Time's cover was "artistically interpreted" [1] and attack ads against Obama darkened his skin [2]. Also of Kerry Washington's skin being made lighter [3].
2. Some people interpreted darkening photos as a political move, embodying a belief that dark skin is scary. And lightening the photos as embodying a belief that light skin is more beautiful.
3. Photographers can't keep their hands off the postprocessing tools. And even if they could, they've still got to choose an aperture and exposure when they take the photo.
4. Some people would say, because lightening and darkening black people's skin is political, and photography can't avoid lightening and darkening, photography is inherently political. (and that saying you don't photograph black people is more political, not less)
Of course, some would see that argument as a bit of a stretch. I can understand where it's coming from I just don't agree - or at least, I'm not sure what it means in terms of my personal actions.
[1] http://hoaxes.org/photo_database/image/darkened_mug_shot/ [2] https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2012/05/obama-street-... [3] https://www.cosmopolitan.com/entertainment/celebs/news/a3610...
What I don't understand is how the article seems to imply that there's something wrong with that. Consider that
- Photography was invented and for the longest time mostly used in a majority white area. - It makes a lot of sense that, in predominantly white cultural spaces, lighter skin is preferred, as it historically indicated that a person didn't need to work in the open, which implied some degree of wealth. - Most importantly, it seems to not understand how light works. Dark surfaces reflect less light, so there's less contrast between strongly lit areas and shadows, meaning it's both harder to make a photo look clear and for an AI to analyze it.
https://www.npr.org/2014/11/13/363517842/for-decades-kodak-s...
The reason I commented is because that article makes a lot of complaints that drum up outrage. As far as I know are of the complaints all much better explained by either 1) less light is harder to photograph, or 2) photographing bright things and dark things at the same time is harder than photographing just bright things or just dark things.