Take a population where everyone makes $20k per year. Great! It’s equal!
Take another population where half make $30k and half make $50k. Oh no! Inequality!
I’d rather be in the 2nd population.
Take a population where everyone makes $20k per year. Great! It’s equal!
Take another population where half make $30k and half make $50k. Oh no! Inequality!
I’d rather be in the 2nd population.
I don’t think inequality is inherently evil, but it’s critical that we prioritize increasing the supply of all essential goods and services (housing, medical care, education) to create prosperity for everyone and prevent the have-nots from suffering. Via inequality, we can reward people for creating prosperity, but it’s important that this excess wealth only bids up the price of luxuries like yachts and art, not basic needs.
In my experience, the people that support these housing policies are the kind that would rather everyone have $20k instead of $30k/$50k. Opposition to building denser housing is generally more prevalent with "progressives". At least judging from my experience in San Francisco.
There's nothing environmentalist about low density sprawl.
Same with Rose Pak. Sure she maybe owned property, but she didn’t derive her power from it.
The folks making $30k in the second population may now be spending a bunch more in childcare and hours more on their commutes, because they've been priced out of the city and now have travel from further away.
As an example: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/17/business/economy/san-fran...
Pricing people is not an inevitable consequence of population growth, it's the consequence of an older generation of haves deciding that younger and less wealthy people do not deserve housing in a city.
Which, given that it seems to happen pretty much everywhere, must be factored into decision making.
"Wouldn't it be nice if humans didn't act like humans" is the sort of dreamy optimism that kills Communism.
You can have high inequality without prices rising - it’s a separate problem.