If it isn't acceptable to use an AI to create biased outcomes how is it acceptable to use people to create the the same outcomes. AI decision making can be examined and tuned in ways that people cannot.
If it isn't acceptable to use an AI to create biased outcomes how is it acceptable to use people to create the the same outcomes. AI decision making can be examined and tuned in ways that people cannot.
I don't think people are against using ML and for biased human systems. Just pointing out the ignorant, naive and lazy deference to computers that often occurs in human systems that share the same bias.
In short I'd think most people who are against biased AI are also against biased human systems for very similar reasons.
You can modify reality, but our understanding of biology - especially hormones - clearly tells us that the AI was right: men are generally better than women at weight lifting.
I'm not saying that every issue is like that, but it would be foolish to ignore that sometimes reality is biased, sometimes in obvious ways and sometimes more subtly.
Your post is great for the assumptions it encodes. Like what does it mean to be good at weight lifting? And that for some reason being good at weight lifting is a good proxy for being a good bouncer or construction worker?
For an off the cuff example it’s a great way to demonstrate the sort of bias we can naively introduce then defend because it’s just ‘reality’. When really it’s much more complex than identifying a relevant trait and assuming everything else falls out of it.
being a good weight lifter, means you can lift heavier weights then a less-good weight lifter. Whether this is a proxy for anything isn't relevant, because it's a purely contrived example. There are clearly jobs where physical strength (among other things) is important, and given the context of this example, there is no guarantee that a more complicated model evens out the differences.
The point of the example is, basically "there are some things which might discriminate strongly on the basis on physical traits, which might end up correlating with race/sex etc" - ask for a better model by all means, but there is no guarantee the perfect model will never correlate strongly with some political demographic, and hence be controversial.
"bias" and "reality" can equally cover for model simplicity.