For something this exceedingly, impossibly rare I’d expect an in-depth discussion of how this is NOT an instrument mistake or a mis-interpretation of the measurements. There appears to be none of that.
I've heard suggestions that the result is more of a curiosity than of fundamental importance, and that this is why they get to publish a uncertain result in nature.
Particle physics has a lot of events, so locally improbable things get likely when considering the totality of the data sets.
The particle physicists in the collaboration were by and large against calling it a discovery. The astronomers (by and large) shared your sentiment about the particle physicists being curious folk. :)
Look for the discussion of backgrounds.