Just like the concept of the mythical man-month, the marginal utility of investing additional money in r&d goes down as r&d spend goes up. Or to put it a simpler way, Apple is running out of effective avenues to invest their money.
The correct move in that situation is to return the capital to shareholders, and stock buybacks are the most tax-efficient way to do so, with the added benefit that if the stock is undervalued (and Apple's certainly has been in the last few years relative to free cash flow), then the shareholders get an "extra" return on top of that.
Don't get me wrong, Apple should absolutely invest in R&D...which they do. They're not pinching pennies, except in situations like the keyboard fiasco, not including adapters etc - but that's a separate issue.
Absolutely the worst thing they could do is just go acquiring companies that don't actually fit with their business model. Remember that it takes human effort (meaning cognitive expenditure) to run a business, and getting side-tracked with non-critical businesses is absolutely antithetical to that. If/when Apple does find a company that has something unique for their situation, then they do acquire them.
This would be true if there are no new products with huge potential to explore. I strongly believe any company's future depends on diversification. Your old products will eventually start becomming commodity with margin race to the bottom. Companies like Apple needs to come up with new product line every two years. To get one new product out, you need to invest in R&D for may be 10 internally because other 9 won't pan out. For each new product you eventually got out, most likely half might not show promise longer term to become big. So you are probably left with 1 big product coming out every 4 years and at the same time your previous big product that is ~12 years old starting to become low margin commodity. Apple is certainly doing great by putting out series of new products at predictable schedule but I think this could easily be twice of current rate given the untapped potential in so many areas.
In any case I am still very bullish overall on Apple and I can't wait for ARM based Macs.
They're not pinching pennies - except they're obviously pinching pennies across the board, no long cable in macpro box anymore, no headphone dongle in iphone box anymore, no extra tips in apple pencil case anymore etc etc.No product recall on the garbage keyboard design is another penny pinching move imo, they've lost so much goodwill coz of that garbage design.
I think the reality is quite different from what you're painting. They're cash bloated and dunno where to go because they've painted themselves into the "we're the best" corner
120hz
Airpods, and the new embedded chips
AR, certainly an upcoming headset
A failed vehicle program
Others?
Airpods - a proprietary bluetooth stack that only runs well with apple devices, wow much r&d. They run well but samsung mostly replicated the proprietary bluetooth stack for their own earpod/works with galaxy only pairing solution.They also die in a year with average use so imo it's just more electronic fad garbage.
AR- vaporware currently to the point where they're talking about the credit card as a selling point. also AR in general is garbage on current gen devices. it's fun but it's not useful.
vehicle- failed.
Apple acquires small companies all of the time to integrate technologies into their core products and as acquihires.
How would acquiring companies like Netflix or Disney add any goodwill value - the sum is greater than its parts?
If they acquired Qualcomm, not only would they run into possible antitrust concerns, they would either continue selling to competitors (not likely) or lose a large amount of the value of the company
As far as the next big thing. The mobile phone market was already on a trajectory to have worldwide ubiquity before the iPhone was introduced and now has 66% world wide penetration. There is no amount of R&D that has any hope of achieving more worldwide penetration than the “computer in your pocket” market - except maybe social media. Do you really think that Apple should jump into that market?
if apple has so much excess capital that it can net icahn 2 billion dollars in a couple years, is that excess capital (that is ostensibly being generated by its employees) being “returned” to them as well?
It is all about value. Apple has always been extremely good at value creation. That is what innovation is all about. Except the values Apple has to offer has been in decline, in iPhone and Mac Segment, and in their use of cash.
Looking back in the past 10-12 years of Smartphone revolution, we are obviously in the late cycle where even the entry $200 to $400 Model are good enough for many. We are already seeing Huawei and Samsung A Series doing extremely well. I had always thought those Cheaper Chinese SmartPhones such as Oppo, OnePlus, Vivo, Xiaomi, would have cost a lot more in EU and US when they had to pay more patents and other operation expenses. Turns out that is not true. They are selling it at only a slight premium to China's pricing, vast majority of them below $500. While the current cheapest iPhone starts at $449 for a "small screen " and $569 for what is now considered a normal screen in many market, with lower quality camera. And it is obvious these Phone aren't competing very well.
What could those $400B+ have done that went into Stock buyback over the years? I would have thought instead of going to Intel's route 5 years ago, having their own modem team would be one. Had they invested in it 5 years ago they would already have their own Modem shipping in 2018's iPhone. Not to mention having a major BOM cost advantage which both currently Huawei and Samsung enjoys.
Opening More Apple Stores, Apple had ~430 in 2014 and ~460 Stores by end of 2015. Today Apple had ~510 Store Worldwide.they now have 1.4B devices. During those 600M+ devices usage increases between ~2015 - 2019, Apple had less than 60 Stores opening world-wide. In 2015 I expected Apple Store to reach at least 1000 by 2020, but right now they are only half way there.
Quickly admitting mistakes like TouchBar and Keyboard. You may not even need to do recall, but actually work on alternative or better solution instead of waiting to recoup whatever your initial investment into the technology ( Also Force Touch ). This is very Tim Cook Style of handling. You could imagine Steve using the Keyboard himself, having space bar double spacing and the eee key stuck. And what he will do inside Apple Park.
Going into Market that may not always have your target Gross Margin and Net Profits. Like TV, I still don't understand why Apple is not entering the TV set Market. And why they abandon the Router market. Just because the Net Profits margin could not fit within the 20% required of Apple. Both would have been a much better experience, instead they went with a Profit Margin based product like HomePod.
The TV set market has long life cycle, negative margins and the main way that TV manufacturers make money in 2019 is by selling user information through the apps.
The router market is minuscule. Most people use routers bundled with their ISP and Apple couldn’t provide the end to end support without also going into the ISP business.
Which is precisely why Apple needs to enters it? And negative margins - It is not like Apple is targeting the lower end of TV spectrum anyway.