The alternative, potentially better, theory is that everyone is reacting to the same incentives and market structures. Governments are pushing electric vehicles through subsidies and mandates. Meanwhile, exploding use of portable electronics has led to massive improvements lithium ion battery technology. Tesla has targeted a flashy niche market, expensive sports sedans, but has largely avoided trying to compete in the markets where the sales really are: crossovers and SUVs. (Every year, Toyota sells as many RAV4s as all the vehicles Tesla has ever sold.)
In Beijing, I saw a lot of Model S’s on the road in the year before I left. These people would have been driving Audi A5+ or an S-class if it wasn’t for Beijing’s plate lottery (you can get a car quicker if it’s an EV). As far as that goes, the Model S is a good strategy outside of the USA where people aren’t so SUV crazed.
Tesla is maintaining a brand halo by keeping a reasonable minimum range, but the base Model 3 is relatively inexpensive compared to many competitors.
Specifically, isn't this because of CAFE[1]? Gas mileage compliance is calculated per manufacturer. So BMW can keep selling 17mpg M3s as long as they're selling enough of those i3s[2]
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_average_fuel_econom
[2] - Which sell for $50K but are like $15K used!
Any comment on whether it's a car that would last to 150,000 miles? I see a warranty of "guaranteed at least 70% capacity for 8 years or 100,000 miles".
Edit: NM, had to widen my search params. I dunno if I'd want to trust a 2015 electric car, though. ;)
And meanwhile, Ford is selling a quarter million F-150 trucks every quarter compared to Teslas total units per quarter around 40k. I don't think the big automakers are worried yet.
[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/24/business/ford-rivian-inve...
While maybe not "worried" Ford sees a risk.
The difference between Tesla and others isn't that Tesla somehow was the first to come up with these ideas, they were the first to attempt to run a car company like a startup and marketing themselves as a disruptor.
Which in a sense is true because it brought the products to the forefront, but there's a reason that hadn't happened before, because a car manufacturer actually needs to make money on the existing markets. No use in pushing a good idea before the time is right.
Does it really matter?
Tesla is doomed. It’s run out of early adopters and its cool factor is diminishing. The last quarter’s results indicate that demand is down. Supply issues can be spun as a positive, but if demand is weakening...
Combine that with increased competition from a half dozen well established players and the writing is on the wall.
The transition isn't urgent due to oil prices. It's urgent due to greenhouse gases making the planet inhospitable for humans.
But a hydrogen economy feels like it could work when scaled up. Somehow it feels practical as the most abundant element in the universe, with high energy density. Lithium/cobalt reserves are limited, though recycling measures might could solve that problem.
Platinum-group element coated electrodes powered by ~25 year life spans of cadmium/tellurium solar cells (or Perovskite, and many others I'm sure, but Cd/Te is the one I've deployed en masse personally) would allow for low maintenance hydrogen generation and a shift away from natural gas sourcing.
Nafion is necessary for the fuel cells themselves but I'm not sure about the production process behind that.
Not to mention that the equivalent mpg for a Tesla is 100mpg.
Add to that the fact that mass produced grid electricity is massively more efficient and clean than everyone generating energy themselves. (ala internal combustion engine).
It would be like saying that everyone having their own gas generator at home is just as bad as having a single gas power plant that powers the grid.
Sure, there are other sources of pollution like the batteries but "all in", electric cars are still significantly better for the environment.