Besides, Huawei gets no sympathy from me. Too many years of stealing IP. Someone had to say no.
Besides, Huawei gets no sympathy from me. Too many years of stealing IP. Someone had to say no.
Other companies implement and manufacture them.
So, wait: do we like intellectual property and patents stiffing innovation, or do we not? Only when it benefits us? I can never keep this straight.
There is a lot of hypocrisy in order to feed the current anti-Chinese campaign but the fact is that everyone behaves the same.
And we all have heard of the many reports of counterfeit goods being basically scavenged from the same assembly lines as the original products. And also seen people try to cut out their business partner and go to their vendors directly, often directly in conflict with their NDAs, because they can save money by going upstream. I can't blame them for the intent, but it's unethical to do so if you promise not to.
These are easy to distinguish from patents. Patents suck for almost everyone, and only have gotten worse now that it's not even clear that I can create something and publish it to the public and actually rely on no one filing patents later down the road for stuff in my public disclosure.
This used to be my strategy with LED lights, I'd just release the schematics, board files, firmware, concepts, etc on my blog and send it to various popular news sites because I'm not interested in getting patents for my stuff (including, it seems, the world's first direct wifi LED color changing lights in 2010, two years earlier than LiFX, but I haven't researched in depth). I just don't want Philips patenting the idea and suing me for doing it later (they did anyway I'm sure).
Example: https://slashdot.org/submission/1393662/arduino-based-high-p...
Getting your companies 10 years of work to develop something commandeered by government fiat, espionage, or corporate malfeasance is very different and I think hurts innovation. Why bother if you know as soon as they copy you you won't be able to compete anymore because you've already spent $100M to develop it and have R&D to pay back.
That's how I heep things straight. Patents work when they help people be rewarded for real work that they have done.