Magic strings and numbers all over the place are less likely to be refactoring artifacts.
Of course he's only human, but it wasn't me who picked this little (80 LOC) file, of all the codebase, as an example of code being like "out of a book or tutorial" :)
And what about stuff such as 20 KLOC in a single file? This is spaghetti, no matter how you spin it. I wouldn't want to work with such codebase.