Makes sense. I do not know from were the 'freedom' argument comes from our relates to this.
Makes sense. I do not know from were the 'freedom' argument comes from our relates to this.
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/MediaWik...
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:Arbitration_Com... (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:Arbitration_Com...)
If my employer demanded I use TFA (they do), and I defaced one of their public web pages, I’d be fired.
Is this what happened? Maybe. It certainly sounds a plausible, but without any transparency, it’s hard to say.
No, IMHO the central office had already decided the ArbCo had already failed to defend itself and the platform from skilled manipulation.
I would expect reforms are on their way
Now ArbCom is a bit irrelevant, the Foundation decides guilt in secret and hands out punishment as they see fit.
This is an intervention that realistically should have been dealt with by the community. If he had posted "Fuck Wikimedia" as well, there could have been another perceived conflict of interest. Sooner or later you run out of conflicted groups of people and what happens then?
Right.
There was another recent incident which generated some drama due to the lack of transparency by Wikimedia, but it ultimately fizzled because the banned user in question was silent and so absent any alternative people assumed that the ban was well justified.
In this case, the banned user has written a calm and clear description of events from their perspective, including paraphrasing the communication they received from Wikimedia.
This discussion has essentially foreclosed the possibility that it was something like child pornography in question-- and, in fact, the specific citation of a rude remark towards arbcom stands out in particular because arbcom apparently had no involvement in the ban.
The community had years to deal with fram, and they decided not to.
I doubt that comment is the issue.
Freedom from any consequences? That isn't a thing.
Should somebody go to jail for saying "fuck the DOJ"?
In your situation what if I now had misspoke and when expecting a temp ban, somehow get perms banned due to new rules? Their was no due process and the wikimedia foundation is no better than an authoritarian government.
If the person in question needs formal rules to not behave anti-social, maybe staying a year off wikipedia is a good opportunity to figure that out.
Seriously we're dealing with adults here, not children. Which actually goes to the root of the problem, the type of personality that spends so much time on editing the website seems to have a problem with very basic civility.
Wikimedia simply promised to be better than that. The ban isn’t the problem, the process getting there is.
The purpose of free speech is to speak without free of being reprimanded for saying the wrong thing in order to communicate more effectively.
Only insecure organizations ban dedicated community members for speaking out of line. In a more open and democratic organization, the governing committee should just acknowledge statement and move on with the shared goals of the community. Especially with Wikipedia where controversy is expected, admins should not self censor with fear of being reprimanded for “thinking/talking” out of line.
And with regards to your chess club, that is your insecurity speaking - your chess club leader may welcome the feedback and try to understand what made you say that in the first place. If the organization is open to feedback and criticism, and if you are a valued member then it should be concerning why u spoke out, since it may affect others too. A club is only as valuable as its members - please remember that.
Behavior matters in society, and we're not talking about the government here. If you want to behave like an asshole you will have a hard time in a lot of places, and that's a good thing for the most part IMHO.
In this case a closer analog would be someone saying "Fuck you" to a judge in court (arbcom), and then the property manager of the courthouse comes (WMF) unbiden by the court and evicts that person from the property and declines to provide any detailed explanation for their actions either to the public or the court.
It might well be that the judge would have eventually found the party in contempt and no one would have had an issue with it... but as it is the public is left confused and concerned about the property manager's use of their right to prevent trespass effectively undermining the authority of the established system of governance.
Just the fact that all these weasel words have to get added should answer the question without them. Of course nobody would even give a shit if you said it once, like said admin said it once. And the best part is, it's totally speculation whether the ban has anything to do with it. So it's basically just a bunch of people saying "I don't know or care why this happened, because I know something for which they would deserve it", which is saying "fuck arbcom" -- not that we know or care about any of the context, at all. Not even saying "fuck you" to a person. I guess if he had said "fuck wikipedia" it should have been more than one year, because after all, that includes arbcom by definition.
I'm pretty sure I said "fuck HN" in other words before, one time I was so mad I actually took a break from posting, and after a year came back with a lot of upvotes on my last comment and a supportive reply.
> Behavior matters in society
This includes the ban, and arguing "my chess club owner would throw anyone giving them lip out instantly, so" with a straight face.
edit: actually, while we don't know for sure what the ban is for, it's pretty obvious it has nothing to do with "fuck arbcom":
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Community_response_t...
> What we can say in this case is that the issues reported to us fell under section 4 of the terms of use, as noted above, specifically under the first provision entitled “harassing and abusing others.”
My description of much of this as "I don't know or care why this happened, because I know something for which they would deserve it" is correct - it's just not flattering.
There is a flaw in your logic above "I personally don't like the self censorship approach. You must come from a more authoritarian culture" this is a deduction and assertion with no support; the GP may come from anywhere and it is perfectly reasonable for them to come from a very libertarian culture and yet hold opinions that are contrary to your opinion.
The sustained pattern of behaviour that the community failed to deal with was what caused the ban.
"Fuck arbcom" is the reason the ban was handed out by WMF and not arbcom.
But I see this is going to be a "it's a private organization, you mustn't critique it" thread.