> The people of whom you speak would need to be gifted communicators.
Going about it one way yes, but not all ways.
For example, if you could alter the HN guidelines to include new rules like:
- do not state speculation as fact
- be careful to not confuse beliefs based on facts with beliefs based on heuristics
- just as you realize it is foolish to say "people of ethnicity X do (or will do) Y", also realize it is similarly foolish (in most cases) to say things about various groups of people. Realize that you cannot read minds and cannot predict the future, so do not do it in comments.
- be mindful that there's a difference between fact and opinion, and it's often very difficult to tell the difference (errors hidden in axioms, etc)
- do not lie; try to not write untruths
- etc (I can't recall all the ideas I've had over time)
If you made some reasonable changes like this, and actually enforced them, do you think it would not (could not?) make a change? Perhaps the very idea seems absurd, but if you stop and think about it for a while, is it really? You can go into any non-technical thread, and it is full of utterly delusional statements, and it keeps getting worse. I simply cannot believe people as intelligent as those who frequent HN are not capable of significantly decreasing this behavior.
I also don't see a plausible way that this problem gets fixed otherwise. Perhaps some amazingly persuasive enlightened guru could spring onto the world scene and wake people up, but I have a feeling he wouldn't get a very warm reception, from a wide variety of powerful people.