Outside of that it's much more of crapshoot. The trouble is that if nobody has any particularly deep knowledge of the subject then it's a case of the blind leading the blind. People will make arguments that sound reasonable and those will gather the most upvotes. Even if they're wrong or nonsensical in the context. It can be worse if people think they know about a subject purely because it's adjacent to (or looks similar to) something they do know about. Then you get strong but uninformed opinions.
In this environment a domain expert can be at best ignored or even downvoted if their comments seem to go against the grain. So they are in the position of either having to do the "do you know who I am?" dance (which some people don't like) or hope someone does it for them.