Ideally, everything one says should be sincere, so your idea sounds weird to me. I think I understand you want more options in the communication medium of text since we can't have body language and voice tone here.
Personally, I just try to be consistent with my expressions. If my "Thanks." is always used in situations where I'm "sincere" or "deeply appreciative" or otherwise, then that's what it means from me.
There are people that express themselves with absurd amounts of exclamation points and all sorts of hearts and blushing emojis, and I understand that they haven't gone absolutely crazy for me because of that. I just keep tabs in the different expressions different people have for the same things.
The meanings of expressions are determined by those who use them.