So what about leveraged buybacks?
Because there are large parts of the market who don't invest across the capital structure (ie they only buy debt or only buy equity), this can still lead to better allocation of capital.
The market isn't perfect but if companies are really mortgaging their future to provide shareholder returns today, that would seem to be something easily noticed when analyzing the company's financials... thus weighing on future profitability and acting as a counterforce to the boost from the buyback.