RISC-V itself? The core design seems very academic. Seriously, who omits rotate instructions?
RISC-V itself? The core design seems very academic. Seriously, who omits rotate instructions?
People forget that RISC comes out of researchers doing analysis of instruction use, and removing stuff you don't use much - if you can bump the clock speed by 5% by halving the size of a full barrel-shifter then you can execute more instructions per second even if you have to use 3 to do a rotate
[Edit] The principle of removing unused/rarely used HW goes for a toss since now you have a bunch of operations from these extensions that would lie unused yet consume HW. It is not the basic operations that cause bloat, it is the functional variants - need to support different width, indexing, different constant. In this case shift and rotate have the same function. Immediate ones are the variants.
"Academic."
I suspect the base core and may be the FPU will remain relevant (because by then it would be legacy with vast amount of software base), however the other extensions will be superseded/replaced. This will lead to managing the extensions with conflicting encoding like one has to manage different SW library versions.