Approximately 0%. I don't know of any entities that trade as a nonprofit. The point is that if you find something the market needs, you will have inherently discovered an opportunity that can make money because there is demand which exceeds supply for the service. As an additional benefit, such strategies are unlikely to run afoul of regulatory oversight or be eliminated through future rule changes.
> I think the markets are way too complex to rationalize "improving a market".
This is not rationalizing, it is about how to effectively identify profitable opportunities. Let's turn the argument around. Do you expect a trading strategy that harms a market to be reliably profitable without risking fines, banning, or imprisonment? If you don't, then it probably makes sense to exclude such approaches from your strategy search space. Additionally, I would argue that strategies which are of neutral benefit to the markets are likely to generate small returns relative to their risk because entities on the other side of your trades are not receiving value and thus the market is more likely to turn against you. If we eliminate "harmful" and "neutral", we're left with "beneficial".
I completely agree with everything else you say.